It seems from my experience that WP:RD2 is usually
interpreted fairly
narrowly, at least in the cases I've tried to use it. Specifically it
requires the material to be "grossly" offensive and excludes
"'ordinary'
incivility". In the world of Wikipedia, grossly offensive is a pretty
high bar it seems. Right now, I have a hard time even convincing people
that this sort of stuff is incivil, much less worthy of revision
deletion.
My favorite example is the Talk Page for Rubyfruit Jungle. It took 4
years, 10 editors, and a couple of edit wars to remove a joke posted by
an anonymous IP about vaginas smelling like fish.
Ryan Kaldari
It is the responsibility of administrators to apply WP:RD2 fairly and
appropriately.
Fred