Tim Starling wrote:
I don't really want Gerrit putting words into my mouth regardless of how nice they sound. There will always be cases where the phrase is inappropriate and offputting, regardless of which one you choose.
I agree with Tim here, I was thinking the same on this thread. Gerrit makes it look as if the users really said that, where it's just a predefined text, and you can't even edit it.
How about "Set code review score to -1"? Then a more personal message can be typed by the human doing the review.
I was thinking something like «Changed state to "Needs to be improved"», but that of course is confusing when there are several people involved, as all of them are taken into account (until someone removes them and they vanish into the ether).