Lewis Cawte wrote: [...]
I do agree that some of those gadgets should not be extensions, however for example, Twinkle, would be a very nice extension, as noted from various blips of activity from site owners over IRC.
-- Lewis Cawte
Maybe, but when done as an extension imho it should be integrated in MediaWiki with it's own preference page, adding the actions as actual actions and interface messages etc. Not as an extension that loads a few javascript files.
Including for example non-JavaScript fallback (not as a goal but as a result of it being integrated).
-- Krinkle