Of course, here I am trashing him out, in a forum he'll likely never read and wouldn't care to know whether it exists or not.
He had been notified of this discussion before I saw this, and of the discussion on Jimbo's talk page.
And I bet you that there's a good chance he just decides never to edit again in the face of this.
If it were to be replicated with all the other editors like him, would that be the ideal result? It seems to me that you don't usually solve a problem of editors chasing people away from the community by chasing the editors who caused the problem away, because that's simply redefining the parameters of exclusion.
Daniel Case
I doubt he will leave, but he was certainly in need of some feedback. Feedback mechanisms are essential to the functioning of any complex system.
Fred