Please could somebody of the developers deactivate the image upload on nds.wikipedia?
I made a request for this on the wiki since July [1]. There were little response to this (but this is not astonishing, because there a few regular contributors at all) and no real concerns against it. Reasons for the deactivating are, that we have no expertise on legal issues regarding images so we couldn't sort out violations of licences effectively if such would occur. Additionally we have only generated around 100 images in two and a halv years of existence of which I already deleted 50, because they were duplicates of images which are now on Commons. So it seems better, when users of nds.wikipedia esteem the Commons as their main image repository.
Thanks Slomox Admin on nds.wikipedia
[1] http://nds.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Ik_bruuk_H%C3%BClp#Hoochladen
Hello Marcus,
Thursday, October 27, 2005, 8:05:56 PM, you wrote:
I made a request for this on the wiki since July [1]. There were little response to this (but this is not astonishing, because there a few regular contributors at all) and no real concerns against it. Reasons for the deactivating are, that we have no expertise on legal issues regarding images so we couldn't sort out violations of licences effectively if such would occur. Additionally we have only generated around 100 images in two and a halv years of existence of which I already deleted 50, because they were duplicates of images which are now on Commons. So it seems better, when users of nds.wikipedia esteem the Commons as their main image repository.
I think it is wrong to disable image uploads on any Wikipedia. Users should have place to upload any images that are either 1) interesting only to this local wikipedia, not any other; 2) not totally free, just fair use or smth.
While you are admin, you should enforce right copyright policy and delete unappropriate images; but you shouldn't request blocking the ability of uploading at all.
IMHO.
I agree.
You can also post a message to the effect of "Image uploads to this Wiki are discouraged, please use Commons instead".
That way, you will get less uploads.
Mark
On 28/10/05, monk@zoomcon.com monk@zoomcon.com wrote:
Hello Marcus,
Thursday, October 27, 2005, 8:05:56 PM, you wrote:
I made a request for this on the wiki since July [1]. There were little response to this (but this is not astonishing, because there a few regular contributors at all) and no real concerns against it. Reasons for the deactivating are, that we have no expertise on legal issues regarding images so we couldn't sort out violations of licences effectively if such would occur. Additionally we have only generated around 100 images in two and a halv years of existence of which I already deleted 50, because they were duplicates of images which are now on Commons. So it seems better, when users of nds.wikipedia esteem the Commons as their main image repository.
I think it is wrong to disable image uploads on any Wikipedia. Users should have place to upload any images that are either 1) interesting only to this local wikipedia, not any other; 2) not totally free, just fair use or smth.
While you are admin, you should enforce right copyright policy and delete unappropriate images; but you shouldn't request blocking the ability of uploading at all.
IMHO.
-- Best regards, monk mailto:monk@zoomcon.com
Wikitech-l mailing list Wikitech-l@wikimedia.org http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikitech-l
-- If you would like a gmail invite, please send me an e-mail. Si ud. quiere que le envíe una invitación para juntar gmail, envíeme un mensaje. Si vous voulez que je vous envoie une invitation à joindre gmail, envoyez-moi s.v.p un message. Se vce. gostaria que lhe envie um convite para juntar gmail, favor de envie-me uma mensagem. Se vuleti chi vi manu 'n invitu a uniri gmail, mandatimi n messaggiu.
Marcus Buck wrote:
Please could somebody of the developers deactivate the image upload on nds.wikipedia?
I made a request for this on the wiki since July [1]. There were little response to this (but this is not astonishing, because there a few regular contributors at all) and no real concerns against it. Reasons for the deactivating are, that we have no expertise on legal issues regarding images so we couldn't sort out violations of licences effectively if such would occur. Additionally we have only generated around 100 images in two and a halv years of existence of which I already deleted 50, because they were duplicates of images which are now on Commons. So it seems better, when users of nds.wikipedia esteem the Commons as their main image repository.
Thanks Slomox Admin on nds.wikipedia
[1] http://nds.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Ik_bruuk_H%C3%BClp#Hoochladen
Looks like it is disabled.
wikitech-l@lists.wikimedia.org