It is my understanding that this was the consensus, so I have disabled the "minor edit" checkbox for anonymous users. The reasoning here is that an anon can never gain the trust necessary to have his edits ignored by some users.
Note that the checkbox is simply not rendered, an anon can theoretically still get an edit marked as minor with URL magic. I'll try to get to that later.
Regards,
Erik
On 1/3/03 10:56 AM, "Erik Moeller" e.moeller@fokus.gmd.de wrote:
It is my understanding that this was the consensus, so I have disabled the "minor edit" checkbox for anonymous users. The reasoning here is that an anon can never gain the trust necessary to have his edits ignored by some users.
Note that the checkbox is simply not rendered, an anon can theoretically still get an edit marked as minor with URL magic. I'll try to get to that later.
This is not good. Please change it back until this can be better discussed.
This is a wikipedia-l issue, not wikitech-l issue.
The Cunctator cunctator=+4VDYf+6WHMAvxtiuMwx3w@public.gmane.org wrote in news:BA3BAE8A.5DF3%cunctator@kband.com:
This is a wikipedia-l issue, not wikitech-l issue.
If it is for all wikipedia's, it is a Intlwiki-l issue. Wikipedia-l is only the second list of en.wikipedia.
If it is for all wikipedia's, it is a Intlwiki-l issue. Wikipedia-l is only the second list of en.wikipedia.
intwiki-l should be abolished and the wikipedia / wikien-l distinction should be more actively enforced.
Regards,
Erik
Giskart wrote:
If it is for all wikipedia's, it is a Intlwiki-l issue. Wikipedia-l is only the second list of en.wikipedia.
This is a misunderstanding. Wikipedia-l is for policy issues for all wikipedias. Intlwiki-l is for discussion of specific issues of internationalization.
--Jimbo
On ven, 2003-01-03 at 07:56, Erik Moeller wrote:
It is my understanding that this was the consensus, so I have disabled the "minor edit" checkbox for anonymous users. The reasoning here is that an anon can never gain the trust necessary to have his edits ignored by some users.
Note that the checkbox is simply not rendered, an anon can theoretically still get an edit marked as minor with URL magic. I'll try to get to that later.
Thanks, that's a start! Should go into effect shortly as I make upgrades tonight...
-- brion vibber (brion @ pobox.com)
wikitech-l@lists.wikimedia.org