On 6/02/10 6:44 AM, Tei wrote:
On 5 February 2010 20:17, Aryeh GregorSimetrical+wikilist@gmail.com wrote:
On Fri, Feb 5, 2010 at 3:57 AM, Daniel Kinzlerdaniel@brightbyte.de wrote:
Or, to put it differently: let people use "flat tagging", but let's keep the notion of one tag implying another, i.e. math implying science and texas implying america.
And as for [[Category:People executed for heresy]] -> [[Category:Joan of Arc]] -> [[English claims to the French throne]]? That's only two steps, and it already doesn't make sense. You could argue that [[Category:Joan of Arc]] really means [[Category:Stuff related to Joan of Arc]] and shouldn't be in [[Category:People executed for heresy]], but that sounds like it would take as much recategorization work as just using atomic categories -- and much subtler.
off-topic
Not at all, it's entirely reasonable to discuss the problems associated with the current categorisation system, and what methods we'd like to use to improve it.