On 18/07/12 02:41, Rob Lanphier wrote:
Hi everyone,
It appears as though the discussion has continued apace for the Gerrit evaluation process: http://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Git/Gerrit_evaluation
Thank you everyone for chipping in so far. The current format is a mix of talk page and structured discussion, which seems ok for now.
It would appear from reading this page that the only alternative to Gerrit that has a serious following is GitHub. Is that the case? Personally, it seems like Phabricator or Barkeep has the best chance of dislodging Gerrit, but those won't probably get serious consideration without a champion pushing them.
Rob
The evaluation is intended to determine if we want to continue with gerrit or change. If we decide to change, we should then see what we want to change to. Maybe we would finally decide that all the alternatives are worse and end up not changing. Or keeping an eye to anything new which gets published. Or perhaps contributing a LDAP module to some otherwise-fine tool.
Regards