On Fri, Jan 24, 2014 at 11:19 AM, Nik Everett neverett@wikimedia.orgwrote:
At the architecture summit yesterday we had a conversation about the TitleValue proposal and the vast majority of folks thought it was a great start. Something like 10% of us thought the patch _might_ be a start down the path to Javaify MediaWiki. I was one of the 10%.
We resolved to talk more about the commit before merging it because of the objections of our minority. I felt somewhat vindicated. I slept on it. Now I don't think we made the right choice. I think more discussion is a waste of time and we should just keep moving and try to catch the Javaification if it starts creeping in.
I'm disappointed, I thought you'd be our person to watch for the Javaification.
It looks to me like the existing patch *already is* getting too far into the Javaification, with it's proliferation of classes with single methods that need to be created or passed around.