I'm sorry, I totally am not understanding your arguments, why this
discussion couldn't be held in a general way. Sure, for organizing
Wikimania in this city it seems to be important, but I think it is
important for /any/ city. The page doesn't include any arguments that I can
understand which state why it would be /different/ if held in Italy. Or
rather, why it should be.
You do propose already two members of this committee in your plan. I find
that interesting, and not in line with how scholarships are usually
discussed (by an international team, independent of the city), but
personally I would be happy with the two of you being involved in any
scholarship committee, again independent of the bid that wins.
In any case, I feel held back to engage in this discussion if that could be
perceived as support for a particular bid - as I have not studied the bid
itself. I think it would be better for the outcome of the discussion to
hold it outside of that context. But of course you're totally free to hold
any discussion you like, anywhere you like.
Lodewijk
2014/1/12 Federico Leva (Nemo) <nemowiki(a)gmail.com>
Lodewijk, 12/01/2014 17:53:
Out of curiosity, why is this bid specific?
It's explained in the "crucial for the success of this Wikimania plan"
passage and in several other places in the bid, where it's pointed out that
Wikimania needs to be looked at as a whole.
I think it would be much
> more valuable if we can have this discussion independent of the bid.
> These values and goals should be similar independent of the location.
> Even the members of the committee should be mostly independent of the
> location I think.
We don't propose to change the (process of) composition of the committee;
the bid only includes a proposed coordinator/point of contact with the
local organising team, as per handbook/practice (that is me). We're just
telling you one or two years in advance what we plan to do with that. :)
Nemo
_______________________________________________
Wikimania-l mailing list
Wikimania-l(a)lists.wikimedia.org
https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikimania-l