Seems to me like "Guide" is equivalent to "good", and "Star" is equivalent to "featured". "Outline" would be equivalent to "stub", but it's not clear to me whether marking stubs is a good use case for badges.
This raises the question - can client wikis customize the labels shown for the badges? I assume we are currently using the respective item's label in the respective wiki's language (yes, badges are q-items). But we might want to accommodate the respective community's vernacular...
Perhaps a system message could be used to override the label used for the badge?
I'm probably confused, but could we just make a Q item to represent all "Featured" type articles and then make Q items that are sub-classes of that to represent the various different venaculars?
Q1: Featured Items Q2: Featured Articles (subclass Q1) Q3: Barrack Obama (instance of Q2) Q4: Guide Pages (subclass Q1) Q5: New York City (instance of Q4)
Thank you, Derric Atzrott