This is a NSFW photo.... http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Deletion_requests/File:Korean_Vulv...
Five for deletion, two for keep. This is its third nomination.
An admin came in today and declared it being kept because "No valid reason for deletion, per previous decisions. Person is not recognizable."
Were the reasons we provided not valid enough? Can you even challenge something like this? Did I miss something? Am I doing this wrong? Any help would be great,
Sarah
He is correct that a proposal to do something must cite a valid reason, as must comments if they are to be considered when closing a matter.
An image where the person is not identifiable doesn't require their permission. In that he is correct.
I agree it is a particularly poor image that shows nearly nothing of educational value. However the reason you cite, pornographic, does not seem to apply; she is just drying her hair. He does admit "the amount of naked women on Commons is a bit ridiculous"
Perhaps that issue should be addressed as a policy discussion.
Fred