PM, if there is a legal issue it really isn't a good idea to discuss this on an open list. Now, I've looked at the deleted list of sources and it looks like they are fine to me. I strongly suggest you send a polite note to Fred saying so, outlining why each of the sources is clearly an RS and should be valid. But please take this off the list.
Quoting private musings thepmaccount@gmail.com:
a couple of small responses;
Re : William - I respect your judgment and will try and put things more neutrally. I admit that I am losing some faith that a sensible point can be made without many editors immediately flinging insults, but that's no reason not to try......
On http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giovanni_di_Stefano Fred B has said "Don't link to sources which imply information we lack a good source for"
and has deleted the talk page containing heaps of reliable sources (like US Court Doc.s, The Times etc.).
That concerns me.
Re : Steve...
Looks like more clowining to me. Are you planning to contribute something productive to this list, or should we moderate you? Steve _______________________________________________
I don't wish to be moderated - please don't.
best,
PM
WikiEN-l mailing list WikiEN-l@lists.wikimedia.org To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit: http://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l