On 10/24/05, Justin Cormack justin@specialbusservice.com wrote:
On 25 Oct 2005, at 01:35, Anthony DiPierro wrote:
Well, I think all web comics are notable, so I doubt my reasoning is going to change your mind.
I dont have an opinion either way. All I said was that it wasnt immediately apparent from the article to an outsider.
It's immediately apparent that it's a web comic (at least, it is after clicking the links to confirm that it is one). For me, that's enough.
Ok if you cant do that why are all webcomics notable?
Because Wikipedia has no space requirements. We have plenty of room to include all webcomics. To choose to include some, but not others, would allow us to make a statement about what is worthwhile and what isn't. It would violate NPOV. Further, the only people who are going to come across the article are those who are specifically looking for it. Keeping the article in the encyclopedia provides useful information to those people, and doesn't hurt anyone else. If any webcomics are notable, then all webcomics are notable.
If you cant convince me (a broadish inclusionist really, and very
open minded) then no wonder you cant convince the people on afd.
I can't convince the people on afd at least in part because I'm not allowed to make comments on afd.