I don't agree. I a hard argument can be considered by some people as a preasure, while other could not.
In fact, what's the gain in knowing who is reviewing a paper?
2012/11/8 koltzenburg@w4w.net
well, any attempts at pressures or bribes could easily be made known, couldn't they?
On Thu, 8 Nov 2012 09:56:35 +0100, Manuel Palomo Duarte wrote
I don't thnk opening peer reviewing would be a good idea. Reviewer must keep unknown, or she could suffer preasures (even bribes) from authors.
In
my opinion only the editor must communicate with the reviewers
2012/11/8 koltzenburg@w4w.net
agree, ... so it is up to you as a reviewer what you do with your "blindness"
:-)
doesn't this point in the direction of - plus - is + ? I mean: why not do open peer reviewing?
Claudia
On Thu, 8 Nov 2012 09:43:39 +0100, Manuel Palomo Duarte wrote
Even more, you can easily identify the authors because usually they
include
references to their previous publications to build the new
hypothesis ...
2012/11/8 Adam Jenkins adam.jenkins@gmail.com
Most of my reviewing for conference and journals was double blind, although the effectiveness of it was always a bit questionable, as
in
many
cases you can, as a reviewer, identify the author from the style
and
argument. This tends to get worse in specialised areas, where the
pool
of
researchers is necessarily small.
Adam
On 7 November 2012 06:16, Kerry Raymond kerry.raymond@gmail.com
wrote:
I cannot speak for other disciplines but double-blind is not
standard
in Computer Science. ****
Kerry****
Wiki-research-l mailing list Wiki-research-l@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wiki-research-l
Wiki-research-l mailing list Wiki-research-l@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wiki-research-l
-- Prof. Manuel Palomo Duarte, PhD Software Process Improvement and Formal Methods group (SPI&FM). Degree Coordinator for Computer Science. Department of Computer Science. Escuela Superior de Ingenieria. C/ Chile, 1 11002 - Cadiz (Spain) University of Cadiz http://neptuno.uca.es/~mpalomo Tlf: (+34) 956 015483 Mobile phone: (+34) 649 280080 Mobile phone from University network: 45483 Fax: (+34) 956 015139
Aviso legal: Este mensaje (incluyendo los ficheros adjuntos) puede
contener
información confidencial, dirigida a un destinatario y objetivo
específico.
Si usted no es el destinatario del mismo le pido disculpas, y le
pido que
elimine este correo, evitando cualquier divulgación, copia o
distribución
de su contenido, así como desarrollar o ejecutar cualquier acción
basada
en
el mismo.
Legal Notice: This message (including the attached files) contains confidential information, directed to a specific addressee and
objective.
In case you are not the addressee of the same, I apologize. And I
ask you
to delete this mail, and not to resend, copy or distribute its
content,
as
well as develop or execute any action based on the same.
thanks & cheers, Claudia koltzenburg@w4w.net
Wiki-research-l mailing list Wiki-research-l@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wiki-research-l
-- Prof. Manuel Palomo Duarte, PhD Software Process Improvement and Formal Methods group (SPI&FM). Degree Coordinator for Computer Science. Department of Computer Science. Escuela Superior de Ingenieria. C/ Chile, 1 11002 - Cadiz (Spain) University of Cadiz http://neptuno.uca.es/~mpalomo Tlf: (+34) 956 015483 Mobile phone: (+34) 649 280080 Mobile phone from University network: 45483 Fax: (+34) 956 015139
Aviso legal: Este mensaje (incluyendo los ficheros adjuntos) puede
contener
información confidencial, dirigida a un destinatario y objetivo
específico.
Si usted no es el destinatario del mismo le pido disculpas, y le pido que elimine este correo, evitando cualquier divulgación, copia o distribución de su contenido, así como desarrollar o ejecutar cualquier acción basada
en
el mismo.
Legal Notice: This message (including the attached files) contains confidential information, directed to a specific addressee and objective. In case you are not the addressee of the same, I apologize. And I ask you to delete this mail, and not to resend, copy or distribute its content,
as
well as develop or execute any action based on the same.
thanks & cheers, Claudia koltzenburg@w4w.net
Wiki-research-l mailing list Wiki-research-l@lists.wikimedia.org https://lists.wikimedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wiki-research-l