On 7/6/05, JAY JG <jayjg(a)hotmail.com> wrote:
From: "A.
Nony Mouse" <temoforcomments4(a)hotmail.com>
I hereby propose an alternate policy: Page-based 3RR. If the same phrase is
reverted from a page three times in 24 hours, then that PAGE shall be
locked for a week and all editors involved in the reverts shall receive a
12-hour block to cool off.
What a bad idea; it allows any editor to hold pages hostage essentially
indefinitely, even if opposed by dozens of other editors.
Jay.
Perhaps you could add your thoughts for improvement instead of solely criticism?
If we kept the "standard" 3RR in addition to a new page based revert
rule, one editor certainly could not hold pages hostage. I didn't see
anything in the previous proposal that suggested throwing away the old
(but actually pretty young) 3RR rule.
--
Michael Turley
User:Unfocused