Andre Engels wrote:
I don't buy this argument. Either having such a page is good for Wikipedia, and in that case we should not hesitate to generate them, or it is bad, and in that case we should seriously consider deleting them.
Let me defend the asymmetry for a moment.
I think it's perfectly reasonable to refrain from some practices ourselves, because we think they aren't good, while still giving other people a lot of leeway to pursue their own interests, even if we disagree.
This is similar to the distinction between what you _have the right_ to do, versus what you _ought_ to do. You have the right to smoke cigarettes in the privacy of your own home if you want. I'd advise against it, as it's proven to be unhealthy. But it would be wrong of me to try to stop you.
There are often cases where I think it'd be better to not create a certain type of page, but where I think that if someone else did, it's better to just let them do it, even if I wouldn't have.
--Jimbo