2009/1/14 Carcharoth carcharothwp@googlemail.com:
"cleanup" is not an AfD result I've ever seen. It has been a long-standing axiom as far as I can remember that AfD is not cleanup. What *can* happen is someone closes as keep or no consensus, and then *adds* their opinion (or that of others) that cleanup is needed. But that is not a close of "cleanup".
This does not square with practice, where people will aggressively defend whatever the AFD comes out as. "But the AFD consensus was to GUT THAT LIST!"
- d.