From: David Gerard dgerard@gmail.com
JAY JG wrote:
From: David Gerard dgerard@gmail.com
JAY JG wrote:
and when it came to the inevitable RfAR months later (after which the person in question was banned for over a year), none of the evidence presented in the RfC was even considered.
Er, why not? It would likely have been an excellent start to arbitration evidence. Which case do you mean?
As far as I know none of the evidence in my RfC re: Alberuni was used in the actual findings against him.
Ah, okay. Apology on my part for not going looking, that was one of the earliest cases I looked at.
Note to all bringing RFArs: if you've done an RFC, list it on the Evidence page *and* explicitly reuse the evidence!
Just to be clear, I was not a complainant in the RfAR against Alberuni. I explicitly avoided that case for a number of reasons, including ones mentioned earlier on this list.
Jay.