David Friedland a écrit:
Anthere wrote:
Talking about recipees....
http://en.wikibooks.org/wiki/Cookbook%3ASpecial_brownies
should not it be really and seriously deleted ?
Ah, but Anthere, the marijuana brownie holds a special place in the hearts of the subculture of non-legal cookery, that is to say foods made with controlled substances (cuisine illégale?). You can even buy them in certain parts of the US.
- Davi
d
I know that.
I just discussed this on irc, and I was told it would just be censorship to do so. I suggested adding a tag on it, so at least those countries where this type of articles will be possibly illegal, can avoid in the future, any local hosting of such articles, or mostly, any publication in books or CD distributed in the country.
I do not think it was well received.
If I may dare a comparison, many of you agreed to have image tagging precisely to have the ability to avoid publication of anything which might be problematic. For instance, a country might wish to avoid to publish fair use images because this might be legally problematic.
In France, it is illegal to give someone the idea to eat or smoke (or whatever) an illegal substance. An article suggesting to purchase an illegal substance to put it in food, might be illegal (it is called "incitation à l'usage"). Possibly not. Possibly yes.
So, I suggested that in a similar way to fair use image, we could add a tag so as to identify these potentially problematic articles. Just as it may make sense to remind at the top of the article that in some country, the use of some of the ingredients are illegal.
Now, I understand quite well that in other countries, it is legal and just all right. But it is not so everywhere. Such a cookbook would not be okay in France.
I will only say