We need a policy on "titles of articles about slogans".
Most of us would probably agree that the slogan itself should not be the title of the
article:
* [[AIDS Kills Fags Dead]] <= not a good title
How about some convention like "Slogan: XYZ" or "The slogan:
'XYZ'", as in:
* [[Slogan: Death to Moonies]]
* [[The slogan: Moonies stink]]
(Note that I used a slang word for own church in what I hope are two entirely imaginary
slogans.)
Uncle Ed
-----Original Message-----
From: Toby Bartels [mailto:toby+wikipedia@math.ucr.edu]
Sent: Wednesday, March 19, 2003 11:58 AM
To: wikien-l(a)wikipedia.org
Subject: Re: [WikiEN-l] DTK article
In the spirit of [[Aids Kills Fags Dead]] and in honor
of Cungcator ("you
and JD a consensus do not make") rather monolithic view of the article
(considering Axel now endorsed its deletion... ) I have penned [[Death to
Kikes]], an informative article about kikes... and soon to come:
Shouldn't that be [[Death to Kikes slogan]]?
And shouldn't the article be about the slogan, not about Jews?
To be analogous to the AKFD case, that is.
-- Toby