Resid Gulerdem,
You are trying to blame me for your repeated difficulties on
Wikipedia. This is FLAT OUT false as I have already demonstrated by
showing that it appears that wherever you go you are disruptive. Why
do you think you were so frequently blocked on the Turkish Wikipedia,
blocks that I had nothing to do with whatsoever? In my opinion
Wikipedia needs less influence from editors like yourself who'd do
better to leave the project permanently rather than try to create
policy that is ill founded from a contributor who's reputation is
demonstrably ill founded. You would do better to spend your effort
more productively elsewhere rather than being disruptive on both
English Wikipedia AND Turkish Wikipedia
.
-Scott Stevenson [[User:Netscott]]
From:
"Scott Stevenson" <wikinetscott(a)gmail.com>
Reply-To: English Wikipedia <wikien-l(a)Wikipedia.org>
To: "English Wikipedia" <wikien-l(a)wikipedia.org>
Subject: Re: [WikiEN-l] Time to start discussing
solutions?
Date: Sun, 4 Jun 2006 11:15:08 +0200
Resid Gulerdem you are a PERMANENTLY BLOCKED EDITOR
who has not only
been disruptive on English Wikipedia :
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Rgulerdem with
corresponding
extensive block log:
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special:Log&type=block&pa…
but you've been disruptive in an entirely independent
way on the
ridiculous. You
should STEP AWAY from the project for at minimum 1
YEAR and then come
back to try and contribute as at this point it is
surely likely that
you'll once again be disruptive when trying to
formulate any sort of a
"policy" like [[WP:OURS]] through
demonstrating the
same types of
disruptive editor behaviour you've already
repeatedly
demonstrated
(involving WP:OWN, WP:3RR, WP:POINT, WP:NPA, and
WP:CIV).
>
>-Scott Stevenson [[User:Netscott]]
On 6/4/06, Resid Gulerdem <resid_gulerdem(a)yahoo.com> wrote:
Dear Scott,
What is your panic for? My account is blocked, yes!
This is the third time you are repeating the same
thing on this list. I disclosed that at the beginning
of the proposal too. I hope people smart enough here
to see that you are trying to denounce the proposal by
mud-throwing at me. I expect you will continue doing
so to distract the attention of the community from the
proposal itself. I had issues with some admins,
blocked at the end and '''that is why I know the
admin-abuse problem by heart'''. I am trying to make
some structural suggestions so that new comers do not
live through the same difficulties I had here. Isn't
that really understandable to you? If you would like
to talk about the issue, focus on the proposal and
find some mistakes in it, that would be more
persuasive that I am doing bad and be more useful to
correct it.
I am so sorry to say that you are not an exemplary
editor in my sight from whom I can take some advise,
and maybe in the sight of a few other users you are
messing up around. I do not want to waste my time to
provide links to show what kind of editor you are.
(There are already two links in my previous message,
accidentally.)
Maybe I should just say this: It is no good to watch
each and every step of a fellow editor and try to
create a negative atmosphere around him by distorting
the facts, slandering, using your experience and
naivety of the new users in a negative manner, biting
the new users, trying to spoil any positive relation
the user may have by secretly talking to others,
organizing other users against a fellow editor etc. It
is not also good to spoil and ruin the articles and
proposals by starting edit-wars, reverting without
discussion, tag'ing the articles at which you have no
other contributions or idea about without any
explanation, etc. I cannot see the basis for your
motivation and do not like to describe it in terms of
phycology for the sake of kindness. I just want to let
you know that those are the behaviors that damage the
community spirit of Wikipedia.
I want you not answer it to me but ask this question
yourself: What will I gain from ruining another
proposal ([[WP:OURS]]) as I did in the case of
[[Wikipedia:Wikiethics]]? Is mud-throwing ethical and
can considered among the behaviors of a gentleman?
Should I stop this poor behavior? If you have
difficulty to find an answer please consult your
parents for your childish behavior.
If you remember, I told you 'bye' far ago. When I say
it, I really meant that. Let me see if I can make
myself more clearer this time: Bye again...
Resid