* Sascha Noyes <sascha(a)pantropy.net> [2004-02-12]:
On Thursday 12 February 2004 12:40 pm, John C. Penta
wrote:
Comparing a debater with a murderer is not
helpful...
I do believe Sascha has caused Godwin's Law to be invoked...
Read what I wrote again. I did not compare a debater with a murderer. This is
a strawman attack, and you know it.
Here is the core to which you are objecting:
"extremists (Nazis, suicide bombers, etc.)
are extremely fond of your idea of
there being absolute black and white values."
Do you thin that this statement is untrue, or do you simply have no arguments
against it?
Non-extremists states, like the US (although this is debatable), are the
only ones having dropped an atom bomb over civilians during a war.
Does this mean that non-extremism is bad?
Just to know if agreeing on
your statement means agreeing on "having black and white values is a bad
thing".
Your statement is true but saying that Hitler was a Bayern Munich
supporter does not imply that Bayern Munich is a bad team or that nobody
should ever support it. History is not an argument in any discussion.
Just after getting annoyed.
Pedro.
--
Pedro Fortuny Ayuso:
http://pfortuny.sdf-eu.org
Colegio Mayor PeƱafiel, Universidad de Valladolid
C/ Estudios 6, 47005 Valladolid, Spain -->
www.cmpenafiel.org
pfortuny(a)sdf-eu.org Tfn. Nr. 34 983 298277