On 08/12/2007, Jimmy Wales jwales@wikia.com wrote:
Alec Conroy wrote:
On 12/5/07, jayjg jayjg99@gmail.com wrote:
First of all, Matt and Guy and Slim can't lie about something they can't possibly have known. The truth is, they have no clue whether the list was used to coordiante or not. Durova posted to the list about !! to the list-- what responses she got back through email, only Durova and her sleuths know. People can say "I didn't see any full-formed coordination", but they can't actually know there was no such coordination.
So we now have established that the list was not secret and was not used directly to coordinate the !! block. So Alec shifts gears with a new allegation: maybe people responded *privately* to Durova's post with support.
This is not a new allegation. It follows logically from statements from Durova, Jay and others, too.