On Thu, May 26, 2011 at 5:34 PM, Rob gamaliel8@gmail.com wrote:
On Thu, May 26, 2011 at 2:56 PM, Brian J Mingus brian.mingus@colorado.edu wrote:
Your arguments fail to account for the fact that the article is curated
by
biased anti-Santorum contributors,
Well, you lost me right there. This is a terrible slur on both the editors of the article as well as all the uninvolved editors who have examined the article and found it compliant with Wikipedia policies. Surely if this broad slur that you've made is true, then uninvolved editors on both sides of this issue would have noticed this rampant bias and its effect on the article. This kind of thing, as well as earlier emails here from another editor with dark hints about how the creator of this article also started an article about a gay porn company, is really distasteful. And ironic that the bold defenders waving the banner of BLP would defend a living individual by slurring other living individuals.
I believe you will have a hard time justifying your claim that my comment is false (not to mention that it is a slur). It should be easy to show that the article is curated by at least one, and probably several, biased anti-Santorum contributors.
- Brian