If someone comes to Wikipedia for information on the city that O. Henry
called "Bagdad-on-the-Hudson," and they type in something reasonable...
like "New York" or "New York City" or "New York, New York" or "NY" or
"Manhattan" or "The Big Apple" or even "Gotham," are they going to find
what they seek?
The answer to this rhetorical question is that "Bagdad-on-the-Hudson"
comes up blank, but all the others either take one immediately to a
page with a pretty picture of the Manhattan Skyline and the Statue of
Liberty, or present it as a clearly explained link less than an inch
from the top of the page.
So, even though I personally think that putting it under "City of New
York" is a) pedantic and b) inconsistent, let me coin a motto,
"Wikipedia is not thumb-indexed" and, Emerson, you know, foolish
consistency, hobgoblin etc. etc.
I am not, however, volunteering to update the 501 pages that link to
"New York, New York" to remove double redirects. Somebody _was_
planning to do that, right? :-)
--
Daniel P. B. Smith, dpbsmith(a)verizon.net