2009/3/31 Fred Bauder fredbaud@fairpoint.net:
Yeh, you would. It is not that good. It is inconsistent and fails to adequately define many terms because "Wikipedia is not a dictionary" and fails to provide appropriate external links because "Wikipedia is not a web directory".
Those are not something you want out of a redirect or disambiguation system. You want something that can tell the differences between cases like [[HMS Victory]] where it's safe to assume that people are talking about the one that was nelsons flagship and [[HMS Iron Duke]] where you are better off questioning further. You also want a system that highlights the key distinguishing features of whatever is being disambiguated.