On 13/03/2008, Sage Ross sage.ross@yale.edu wrote:
Whoa! Undue weight governs coverage within individual articles, and has no bearing on whether a topic should have an article. Wiki is not paper, really. (And even paper coverage greatly exceeds Wikipedia's current coverage on almost any given topic, in aggregate.)
You're strictly correct. OTOH isn't this somewhat equivalent to arguing that it's perfectly OK to remove something from an article (or even lots of articles if they all mention it) on NPOV grounds, and then turn around and make an article especially for it?
-ragesoss