Charles Matthews wrote:
"David Gerard" wrote
On 06/03/2008, Philip Sandifer snowspinner@gmail.com wrote:
I will repeat my conviction that our notability guidelines are the biggest PR blunder we engage in.
No, it's second to BLPs. Not third, however.
Ha-ha, {{sofixit}}.
I would, but I suspect my edit putting {{historical}} on [[Wikipedia:Notability]] would be reverted and I would be berated for it. Not as bad as the response to deleting AfD was, but probably just as effective in the long run.
We don't _need_ notability, or anything like it. Our other existing policies would suffice to keep the actual "crap" out.