On 7/23/08, Jonathan Hughes <lifebaka(a)gmail.com> wrote:
Wouldn't it be just a bit easier to have admins go
on wikibreak instead?
It'd have the same effect (assuming either works) and without the stigma of
desysopping. Or else suggest that admins voluntarily stop doing admin
things for a while.
Absolutlely-- those are all options an arbcom could draw upon too in
trying to mend the situation.
Another middle-ground that I don't think I've seen before-- eliciting
a promise from admins to stop using their tools until being
"re-confirmed" by a RFA or Arbcom-- BUT, keeping the bit in place,
letting the user still be an admin, and not have the stigma.
And I should say, despite this thread, I'm not actually lobbying for
desysopping or anything--- I'm just trying to find options in the
middle ground. middle-ground. Arbcom seems to be deadlocked or
otherwise stuck, George Herbert makes some excellent points, and it
seems reasonable to brainstorm solutions that lie between "Person is
commended" and "Person is hereby desysopped, with extreme prejudice.
"
Maybe if assigning fault isn't something people can find consensus on,
perhaps consensus could be reached through just focusing on how to
limit the potential for the conflict to continue unabated or for it to
expand.
Tricky situations abound. Perhaps the solution is to admit we don't
know if "you were bad" or not-- we can't agree on that. But we do
know "the project might be better off if you let the other 1500 admins
handling conflicts". Just a for example.
It's also possible, though I might say not likely, that the situation
could be resolved by just ignoring the factionalism problem GH
discusses but dealing very firmly with the more black-and-white
breaches of policy. If everyone involved were on a very tight
civility leash, for example, maybe flames would die down through a
ripple-effect the resolves the community issues.
I dunno. Very complicated, very tricky. At this point, almost any
solution is worth considering. See if Jimmy Carter is available to
come mediate between SlimVirgin and Cla68? All disputes to be settled
by a Mesoamerican Ballgame competition? Personally, I think our best
hope is for the foundation to buy a giant searchlight that says "New
York Brad" on it, shine it up into the clouds as a signal, and hope
that NYB, despite his secret identity having been exposed, will to
return to arbcom and save us all. (ala
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bat_signal and the general consensus that
NYB is, in fact, a supehero :) )
Alec