Maybe the best thing to do would be to move on from arguing about the rollback proposal and develop some bureaucracy that governs how proposals like this should move forward in the future. As folks have been saying, the feature itself isn't a big deal. Since admins can grant it, and there are a lot of admins, they should be able to grant it through RfR or any other way they want. The issue was the proposal and implementation process (or lack of process) so we should skip right into debating that instead.
Nathan