It's hysterical watching this whole process. Untold legions of electrons marching to their oblivion in the name of..well, I don't think I know any better than anyone else.
Prediction; this process will become hopeless bound up in process and bureaucracy, all the while having people saying "give it a chance!" Then when it's obvious how blatant of a failure it is, it will be so entrenched that it will be impossible to do away with or reform.
Case in point; RfA. What was originally a light process, intended to grant privileges to just about all comers has turned into a ridiculously stupid bureaucratic nightmare with an unimaginable amount of bureaucracy and rancor. What was previously done just via the mailing list has turned into La Brea Tar Pits.
This thing has been live for just mere days, and already people are scrambling to contain instruction creep. Guess what? You can't, in the long wrong. Mark my words. And all of this for something that can be done with scripts, or can be done using the "undo" link on edits.
Watching all of this stuff is very comedic expose on human nature and the follies therein.
You don't need a process. You don't need a category. You don't need an archive bot. You don't need to tag anything with {{done}}. You don't need approval. You don't need admins to grant this. Give rollback to everyone, and block the repeat abusers. No need for additional process.
-Durin