"Thomas Dalton" wrote
That's not really the same kind of appeal. The appeals I'm talking about are after a committee of admins has fully explored the issue and made a ruling.
If you're talking about some kind of lower court, then I suspect it would get that kind of traffic; in other words ban appeals. Defining it as a committee of admins (not therefore representatives of the community at large) suggests its natural role to be reviewing of what individual admins get up to.
All the information ArbCom would need to judge if an appeal is warranted should already be there. Judging an appeal of a community ban is much harder, since the information is often much harder to find.
I question both these points.
Charles
----------------------------------------- Email sent from www.virginmedia.com/email Virus-checked using McAfee(R) Software and scanned for spam