On Fri, 13 Jul 2007, Guy Chapman aka JzG wrote:
This site does not have pages, it has threads, every one of which is a ticking bomb because they can beb added to by any subscriber and the bar to subscription is apparently low; all you need is a grudge .
And this is different from wikien-l, and its Web archive, how? You seem to be claiming that open forums are inherently evil.
If you seriously believe that WR and wikien-l are comparable, then we have nothing more to say to each other. At least not until Jimbo says that WR is the right place for philosophical debate about Wikipedia.
They are comparable *in the way described*, which is that anyone can add anything to them, and what is added could potentially hurt someone.