geni wrote:
Aaron Brenneman closing the AFD after having been through arbitration on the webcomics issue is also deeply unsatisfactory.
It would have been difficult to close it in any other direction.
Hardly. The argument by the delete voters was that it was non-notable. Our own "notability" criteria regarding web content says otherwise. Either a guideline is widely accepted, or it is not, and the only worthwhile close here would have been to keep it.
-Jeff