Stan Shebs wrote:
Steve Block wrote:
Isn't that the very definition of a primary
source. Something we seem
loathe to allow. We can't state that "these words were used in this
document on this date". We can't state that this thing existed at this
web address on this date. Sorry, but this is the same thing as
providing a citation for a factual claim made in an article. The OED
make the claim of a specific usage or first usage, and use web sources
to provide the citation.
The difference is that OED editors are experts exercising professional
judgement and putting their reputations on the line when they make their
assertions.
I thought Wikipedia was an attempt to write an encyclopedia without
worrying about professional judgement, that we could add anything and as
long as it was written from a neutral point of view and was verifiable
it didn't matter. I hadn't realised that we couldn't do some things
because Dave said so.
WP *really* doesn't want much to do with primary
sources;
No, that's your opinion of what Wikipedia does and doesn't want. We
have the occasional featured article built on primary source, so the
community may not agree.
very few
amateurs even know how to evaluate the trustworthiness
of a primary, or
how to reconcile multiple contradictory primaries, and we just embarass
ourselves when we play at that. Unfortunately many WP editors are
unaware of how much they don't know.
No, that applies to Wikipedia across the board. Not many people know on
what topic to start an encyclopedic article, if we look at the speedy
category. That doesn't stop us creating new articles. And that's
ignoring the logical flaw in your argument; that the people telling us
we can't use primary sources may actually be the wikipedians who are
"unaware of how much they don't know". Swings and roundabouts. We used
to judge info on a case by case basis. Now we have hoops we can all
jump through and strange and varying criteria we have to meet. Welcome
to Wikipedia, not a bureaucracy in name only.
--
No virus found in this outgoing message.
Checked by AVG Free Edition.
Version: 7.5.432 / Virus Database: 268.16.5/616 - Release Date: 04/01/07 13:34