On Sep 17, 2006, at 3:00 AM, geni wrote:
Both policies direly need a basic common sense check - don't challenge material you don't actually doubt the accuracy of. Editors should read skeptically and critically, but they should not go removing things for the sake of removing them.
You realise process says exactly that?
No, I don't. The closest thing [[WP:V]] says is "some editors may object if you remove material without giving people a chance to provide references."
You want book length policy pages? No thankyou.
No - I want policy pages based on a book. Do try to read what I'm saying before you respond. I know you like unhelpful one-line replies, but they're not really my thing. The relevant sections of Craft of Research are about ten pages long, and could easily be summarized further.
-Phil