On 03/05/06, Rob Church robchur@gmail.com wrote:
Your opinion is that; and neither wrong nor right. I'd fight for your right to have it, but I would fight you before it was thrust upon another.
Without going into specifics, this is the problem with things like RfA and AfD. We have a set of principles that decisions are meant to be based on. But ultimately, the most flawed reasning is worth pretty much as much as the best reasoning.
Except that in the case of RfA, we don't even have agreed principles that decisions should be based on, so all reasoning is good reasoning.
Steve