What would *exactly* be on the english meta ?
What would editors do there ?
How would we handle duplications with meta ?
I can see some benefits for an english meta, but if the only arguments to set up one are 1) editors will have the benefits of following english wikipedia rules ----> what about the other projects in english ? 2) that meta will be clean of any historical pages (most of them actually being from english editors...) I would say that might not be sufficient.
Anthere
Angela wrote:
(I'm copying this to wikien-l since the issue of whether the English Wikipedia needs its own "meta" is probably better discussed there. See http://mail.wikimedia.org/pipermail/foundation-l/2006-March/thread.html for previous mails.)
Alex Schenck linuxbeak@gmail.com wrote:
A.) It would be heavily based upon most of the policies from en.wikipedia. Some things can change, but it will be a site designed with the purpose of being an extention of en.wikipedia instead of an entirely separate project. Meta2 will exist for Wikipedia instead of being a standalone project.
Does the community on the English Wikipedia need or want to be expanded in this way?
There has always been some opposition to moving anything to meta (though perhaps single login will alleviate some of the concerns).
There is currently confusion about what should be on the English Wikipedia and what should be on meta. "Don't be a dick" is on meta, but "Wikipedia:Complete bollocks" is on Wikipedia. Recentism is on Wikipedia, deletionism is on meta.
Is http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Wikipedia_essays supposed to be different to http://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Category:Essays ?
Are chess, quizzes, and humor pages supposed to be on meta or en? (They're currently on both).
Are you suggesting that all of this stuff would move to Meta2? Is there any advantage to that? Is there likely to be any agreement about it within the English Wikipedia community?
Angela. _______________________________________________ WikiEN-l mailing list WikiEN-l@Wikipedia.org To unsubscribe from this mailing list, visit: http://mail.wikipedia.org/mailman/listinfo/wikien-l