On 6/4/06, Roger Luethi collector@hellgate.ch wrote:
On Sun, 04 Jun 2006 18:07:15 +0200, Steve Bennett wrote:
That actually seems to fix the problem. I saw this with The Beatles for example. John Lennon was in category "The Beatles" (thematic), and that category was in "British rock bands" (taxonomic), leading to the conclusion that Lennon was a British rock band.
It's mostly scripts that get confused. I suspect most normal users won't be confused but find that convenient.
Say I navigated down to "British rock bands" (taxonomic), discover The Beatles and would like to see what WP has got on them. With the proposed system, I need to open the article, scroll down to the bottom -- nope, if there is a category for them, the article can't be in it, so scroll back up several pages worth of navigation boxes, external links, and references to spot the "See also" section which hopefully contains a link to the category "The Beatles" if there is one.
I'm not sure we can convince people that it's a win overall.
You could always put "See also: [[:Category:The Beatles]]" (I think that's the syntax) in the description for [[Category:British rock bands]].