Ray Saintonge wrote:
We could ask, "Give an example where you were able to build consensus with someone that you initially disagreed with." I'm convinced that this kind of skill is among the most important.
Not everyone gets into situations where that sort of disagreement comes up. I don't think, in the last two years, I've ever had a situation that would meet your criteria. Firstly, most of the articles I edit significantly are ones I'm interested in, and tend to be too obscure to get controversy on. Secondly, even more of my edits are spelling, grammar, reformatting, wikifying, merges, disambiguations, redirects, very recently categorization... etc. Thirdly, the rest of what I do is quick [rollback] of blatant vandalism that there really isn't a consensus to build for.
"Can fix things after they've gotten into a mess" restricts your set to people who get into messes.
-- Jake Nelson