On 12/26/06, James Hare messedrocker@gmail.com wrote:
Not to mention it could easily get gamed -- imagine if there's five people interested in some band from Deluth no one cares about, except those five people that manage to get the article saved (at least from speedy deletion). System gamed.
We should do what we already do -- speedy delete those that fail to even assert notability, and PROD those that are non-notable despite assertion. If the PROD is removed, then AFD is necessary simply because it makes us look good. Assume good faith across the board.
I see PRODs get removed too often without any reason for the removal being stated. That's behavior that should be stomped out somehow. Not in a punitive way, but we should still get rid of it.
Mgm