geni wrote:
On 12/3/06, Steve Summit scs@eskimo.com wrote:
- [[Template:Replaceable fair use]] says, "If this image is
determined to be replaceable within one week from <today>, the image may be deleted by any administrator. Do not remove this tag." This leaves me wondering what is supposed to happen if, after a week, the image is not determined to be replaceable.
The administrator dealing with the deletion reads the reasons why it is not replaceable and removes the tag.
This actually happened to me. Rather than discuss the issue, the person who had applied the tag reapplied the tag with the edit summary "what part of do not remove this tag do you not understand". I pointed out I was an admin removing it because I didn't agree that it met the criteria, as I noted in my removal edit summary, and that they were welcome to list it at IFD. I was then told that I should list it there because I removed the tag. At this point another admin speedied it because it didn't fit his fair use criteria, namely that book covers aren't fair use in articles on books unless they are first edition covers or something, and I moved onto something more productive.