geni wrote:
Revert wars wouldn't get very far due to the 3RR - it would force people to come to a *consensus* over whether or not to include an article, rather than just voting. I bet most deletions wouldn't be controversial (just as a lot of AfD listings aren't opposed). I don't see how having vandalism in page histories is a problem.
Dan
The 3RR is not massively effective in stoping revert wars. if you have an article that runs down the fault line between inclusionist and deletionist camps then it will have no effect whatsoever (well in theory it could turn wikipedia into a straight democracy).
Thee we have it! Democracy cannot be gay. :-)
Ec