On Sat, 2003-05-03 at 19:51, Erik Moeller wrote:
Cunc-
An additional suggestion: require summaries on non-minor edits. That will help all of us in general, and help patrol trolls as an ancillary benefit.
Bad idea. People will then flag the minor edit checkbox for major edits to avoid running into this restriction. Either make the summary mandatory, or don't. But do not create an incentive for cheating.
If they do that, they will be punished. It doesn't create an incentive for cheating. It makes acts of cheating explicit.