On Wed, Dec 11, 2002 at 10:02:00PM +0100, Erik Moeller wrote:
that Clutch is violating policy. Ed Poor has already repeatedly warned Clutch, but Clutch refuses to comply. Others who oppose Clutch's edits are - CYD - Someone else - RK - Ortolan88 - myself.
Those who support my edits: - CYD - Eclecticology - myself
Clutch has also added whimsical statements, such as characterizing Wagner's anti-Semitic views, which he held from his mid thirties to the end of his life, as "youthful". I suspect that he is trolling Wikipedia to
There was nothing whimsical or unfactual about that statement; Wagners anti-Semitic pamphlet "Judaism in Music" was indeed a youthful writing. Yet, in the spirit of mutual respect, I left it alone when someone else removed it.
Your characterisation of my edits is ad hominem and not justified by the actual facts of the case.
Jonathan