Are you really suggesting that "most scientists find Theory X to be beyond reasonable skepticism." is not an acceptable standard for the exclusion of Theory X from a supposedly scientific encyclopedia?
Hold on, hold on. We're not talking about excluding Theory X from the encyclopedia - Theory X in this case only appears on the article about [[SEPP]], as one of the claims SEPP makes or made. What we're talking about is how we phrase our description of the fact that scientists mostly reject Theory X. I'm happy to agree with Jimbo that we should be a bit more sympathetic, but the reader should be left in no doubt that scientists do indeed reject Singer's claim.
"Allan Crossman" a.crossman@blueyonder.co.uk writes:
Hold on, hold on. We're not talking about excluding Theory X from the encyclopedia - Theory X in this case only appears on the article about [[SEPP]], as one of the claims SEPP makes or made.
I've no problem with it appearing at [[SEPP]], as representing the opinion of SEPP. I've no problem with the page [[Flat Earth Society]], either.
Just keep it away from the scientific opinion.