On Fri, May 25, 2007 at 05:44:51AM +0100, David Gerard wrote:
Neutrality, no original research and verifiability are
not trumpable
by consensus, or even WP:CONSENSUS.
You're stretching here. WP:V and WP:NOR are en.wikipedia policies, not
foundation principles, and could certainly be overridden or overthrown
by sufficient consensus. They were established by consensus and derive
their authority from consensus anyway. I believe it is the case that
en.wp is rare amoung projects in having a verifiability policy at all.
One foundation issue that hasn't been mentioned in this discussion is
the "wiki process" as a central method of deciding content.
- Carl