Dear English Wikipedia community,
my name is Kurt Jansson, I have been a contributor to the German language Wikipedia right since its start in 2001. I am also the president of Wikimedia Germany, the German chapter of the Wikimedia Foundation.
I'm currently writing a diploma thesis about the Wikipedia project and its editions in different languages. It's a qualitative study based on interviews with six different Wikipedia communities. I hope you to answer eight questions concerning your community and the encyclopedia you've created. I have put the questions on a subpage of my user page and would like you to answer them there. You can use the discussion page to discuss your answers within your community and agree on your joint answers.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Kurt_Jansson/questions
Obviously I would like you to answer my questions the wiki way: You may edit the existing answers that are already there, but try to find consensual answers that the core community can agree on. If there are controversial points of view: say so, elaborate on them and point out if one of them represents the majority's opinion.
Deadline for the answers is April the 29th. Of course I will make the results of my study public and publish them under a free license. I am sure this is a great opportunity for every Wikipedia community to tell others about their project and also to learn from others. But of course this will work best if the answers of other communities don't influence your own answers. So if you have to peek, please try nevertheless to focus on an answer that fits best for your own project.
I'm using mailing lists and village pumps to call attention to the interview questions. If you know other or more appropriate places to raise people's attention, please put this notice there.
Thanks for taking part!
Best wishes, Kurt
On 4/17/07, Kurt Jansson jansson@gmx.net wrote:
Obviously I would like you to answer my questions the wiki way: You may edit the existing answers that are already there, but try to find consensual answers that the core community can agree on. If there are controversial points of view: say so, elaborate on them and point out if one of them represents the majority's opinion.
Hi Kurt :-)
I'm a bit confused about the answering of your questions. Do you want individuals to answer from their own perspective, or from a kind of "neutral point of view"? Are people to edit others' answers to better reflect their own opinions? Or should people answer individually, while perhaps commenting on others' answers?
I'm really just raising this out of interest, and for the benefit of participants in your study - I don't think I can really speak with much experience any more on the workings of the English Wikipedia. :-(
All the best,
Cormac
Hi Cormac!
Cormac Lawler schrieb:
On 4/17/07, Kurt Jansson jansson@gmx.net wrote:
Obviously I would like you to answer my questions the wiki way: You may edit the existing answers that are already there, but try to find consensual answers that the core community can agree on. If there are controversial points of view: say so, elaborate on them and point out if one of them represents the majority's opinion.
Hi Kurt :-)
I'm a bit confused about the answering of your questions. Do you want individuals to answer from their own perspective, or from a kind of "neutral point of view"? Are people to edit others' answers to better reflect their own opinions? Or should people answer individually, while perhaps commenting on others' answers?
The idea is that people really work together on the answers. That's what I mean with the "wiki way" (the concept of NPOV, in my view, carries this idea to an extreme). So ideally in the end every community agrees on their joint eight answers to my eight questions, and every relevant POV inside the community is reflected in their answers.
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=User:Kurt_Jansson/questions&ac...
Thanks for asking! Maybe I will elaborate a bit more on the idea in a reminder notice.
Kurt