--- Robert <rkscience100(a)yahoo.com> wrote:
Mav wrote:
Blah, blah, blah Robert. You cry wolf so often
that
I just delete your messages without ever reading
them anymore. I'm sure many other people do the
same.
Robert wrote:
<snip>
Further, Wikipedia users should be aware that
Mav's
claims
are incorrect. Just check the edit history of the
article I
named.
[[Palestinian views of the peace process ]]
Its not a matter of opinion whether or not Anthere
did such
editing and protection;
the only opinion can be on if this was wise.
Like I said before, RK, Anthere's sole edit to the
article was
to add the protection message, and the only opinion
she has ever
expressed about it is, "reversion war was not a very
good choice".
Ergo her actions do not violate [[Wikipedia:Protection
policy]]
in letter or in spirit. Ergo Mav is right: you are
crying wolf.
That nobody else has seconded your complaint, and that
several people
have agreed that Anthere's actions were entirely
correct, might
have told you something. One can only hope.
Robert wrote:
Ironically, only Anthere has actually responded to
the
points in my letter to this list. And she has
replied in a
modest and impartial way which gives me much hope.
She
focused on the content and on the issues I raised, a
lesson
for all of us. However, others have made polemical
statements or personal remarks. Thus:
I responded too, RK, albeit without the same
remarkable patience
Anthere demonstrated in response to your hysterics.
And your complaint about "polemical statements [and]
personal remarks" is a
bit rich; have you forgotten your original email
so quickly?
Robert wrote:
She has picked one version of an article which
deleted and censored all info which did not agree
with her her
anti-Zionist views, and then she protected the page.
<snip>
If your hatred of Israel gets in the way of
following NPOV, then I would suggest working on other
articles.
And much else besides, but I think I've made my point.
Robert wrote:
(A) It looks like mediation can be made on this
article,
between Anthere, Mav, Danny, myself, and others.
Or you could *discuss the article on its talk page*
with those who have shown an interest
in doing so (currently MyRedDice and myself). How does
that sound?
--C. Podles ([[en:user:Mirv]])
__________________________________
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Mail Address AutoComplete - You start. We finish.
http://promotions.yahoo.com/new_mail